As a food critic who has tasted countless milkshakes across New York City, I can confidently say that Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer delivers something unique with their CrazyShakes®. Whether you’re a native New Yorker or just visiting, these extravagant milkshakes are a must-try experience. In fact, they’ve earned their spot among the best milkshakes in NYC.
The CrazyShake® Experience
Black Tap is renowned for its CrazyShakes®, which are more than just drinks—they’re visual masterpieces that scream indulgence. These towering shakes come in flavors like Cotton Candy, Cookie Dough, and S’mores, topped with larger-than-life sweets like giant lollipops, chunks of cake, and full-size brownies. Their creativity and the sheer size of the shakes make them one of the most Instagrammable items in the city.
Craftsmanship Meets Creativity
Each CrazyShake® starts with a high-quality base of thick, creamy ice cream, blended to perfection. What sets these milkshakes apart isn’t just the base but the toppings, which take the dessert to the next level. Imagine a towering milkshake topped with an entire slice of cake, or a mountain of whipped cream adorned with caramel drizzle, pretzels, and cookies.
For those who love themed drinks, Black Tap often releases limited-edition shakes around holidays or events. From their Breast Cancer Awareness shake to their Shark Week-themed treat, there’s always something special to look forward to on their menu.
Flavor Meets Fun
The flavors of the shakes are indulgent but not overly sweet, striking the perfect balance between dessert and drink. Some crowd favorites include the Sweet n’ Salty, loaded with peanut butter, chocolate, and pretzels, and the Cotton Candy Shake, a visual delight topped with cotton candy, rock candy, and a lollipop. Each milkshake is carefully crafted to be both delicious and visually stunning, making it impossible not to share on social media.
Why They’re the Best in NYC
What truly sets Black Tap apart is the experience they offer. When you walk into one of their locations, you’re immediately hit with the buzz of excitement. Whether you’re sitting in their SoHo spot or their Midtown outpost, the energy is palpable. The milkshakes bring a fun, whimsical element to dining, creating memories beyond just the food. In a city with countless milkshake spots, Black Tap’s creations stand out for their creativity, attention to detail, and their undeniable “wow” factor.
Another key reason they top the list of the best milkshakes in NYC is their ability to turn a simple dessert into an event. Waiting for your CrazyShake® to arrive feels like waiting for a special show, and when it finally lands on your table, it’s impossible not to be in awe of its size and presentation. For tourists, these shakes have become a bucket-list item, and for locals, they remain a fun treat for special occasions.
Secondary Perks: More Than Just Shakes
While the CrazyShakes® steal the spotlight, Black Tap also delivers on other fronts. Their craft burgers are just as famous, pairing perfectly with the decadent shakes. Whether you’re indulging in a classic All-American burger or a more adventurous option like the Truffle Burger, Black Tap offers the perfect balance between savory and sweet.
Their fries, crispy and well-seasoned, complement the meal perfectly. Plus, the atmosphere in Black Tap’s various locations feels vibrant and lively, making it the ideal spot for a fun night out or a casual lunch.
Conclusion
For anyone in search of the best milkshakes in NYC, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer is the ultimate destination. Their CrazyShakes® go beyond the typical shake experience, transforming into a visual and gastronomic delight that draws both locals and tourists alike. Whether it’s the creativity, the sheer indulgence, or the Instagram-worthy presentation, Black Tap has firmly secured its place as the go-to spot for anyone with a sweet tooth.
So next time you’re in New York City and craving something extraordinary, head to Black Tap and treat yourself to one of the best milkshakes you’ll ever have. After all, when it comes to indulgent desserts, they’ve set the bar high.
